View our mobile site
Editorial Columns Letters

Do you think Town councillor Don Smith’s idea of turning part of Paddle River into a skating rink is worth exploring?

Yes
59%
No
31%
Maybe
10%

View past polls

Tell me why I should buy the Leader

Apr 24, 2012 06:00 am

Dear Editor,

Well, I hardly know where to start on Tim Bryant’s editorial of April 10th. So I’ll start with the obvious.

All hail Zombie Jesus? Really?

I’m guessing this young man is trying to get a rise out of a community that he surely must know. To what end? Is that the purpose of an editorial? To poke and prod and mock just so that he can sit back and smugly think he’s done his job?

I’m a writer. I have 36 published books to my credit, and ten years worth of articles for your paper. In all my writing I have always strived to do three things. Know my audience, challenge my audience and respect my audience. I believe any good writer, worth their salary or advance does the same.

Tim does none of these with his editorial of April 10th. He is a confused man on a crusade that only he knows the purpose or end result of. He is also a good example of the very quote he uses from Shakespeare - “A tale told by an idiot, full of sound and fury, signifying nothing.” His editorial is rambling and uneven. On the one hand he claims that he sees no problem with MLA’s being on a committee receiving $1,000.00 a month. Then a few paragraphs later he says that someone should have said something earlier. Why? He says he has no problem with this, so why should Someone have said Something. (And aren’t those the kind of words that stir men’s blood to fight for noble causes) After this opinionated meandering he then rails against Raj Sherman who paid the money back. Okay. So what is his editorial stance? I’m puzzled.

So we have this bewildering editorial veering from one side of the opinion spectrum to the other. Then come the piece de resistance; this complete non sequiter - All hail, Zombie Jesus. Wow. A controversial statement striking at the heart of a faith many hold dear. That has never happened to us Christians before. Or Jesus for that matter. Never been mocked. Never been looked upon as brainwashed individuals who don’t know what they do. Never been treated as unintelligent. Sorry Tim Bryant. You aren’t unique. You aren’t a pioneer blazing a trail against those ignorant Christians. You are just like every other person who has choked on the Lamb of God.

My biggest problem is not with Tim’s feeble remonstrances against a God who died for him as well. A God who cares about him whether Tim wants to acknowledge that or not. My problem is having to read this in a paper that we have subscribed to for the past thirty years. A paper that has and should be a reflection of our community. Makes me wonder why I should bother maintaining my subscription.

So my challenge to you, as publisher of this paper is this - give me a reason I should keep getting this paper. Give me a reason I should keep sending you my money so I can read this kind of mindless, meandering dreck ‘that signifies nothing’. If I don’t get a good enough reason, you’ll be getting a request to cancel my subscription and asking for a full refund of the renewal we sent you only a few weeks ago. I know who my Redeemer is. And Tim can rail against Him all he wants on his own dime and on his own time. Just not in a paper I pay money to get.

Carolyne Aarsen

Neerlandia

Comments

Outsider LookingIn said:
I'm just an outsider looking in, who happened to stumble upon this site. I must profess,I'm not an expert on Barrhead, nor am I claiming to be an expert on religion.

But from what I've read, I pray that the hurt Mr. Bryant has caused to Barrhead through his "too little, too late" editorial will be forgiven in time. It seems to me that Mr. Bryant is a young journalist who is still struggling to find his voice and place in the world. Undoubtedly, the "too little, too late" editorial was a profoundly inexplicable and offensive mistake on his part. However, it is worth remembering that he's offered to Barrhead what I can only hope is a truly heartfelt apology. Honestly, how many of us can truthfully say that we didn't make stupid mistakes in our first jobs?

Forgive me if I am incorrect, but when Jesus walked the earth, the people he chose to forgive were ones who had caused a great deal of hurt to their communities. True enough, I'm sure Mr. Bryant is not a scoundrel, thief or a criminal. But it is my humble opinion that it behooves any good Christian to follow the Lord's example by extending a hand of forgiveness to those who have wronged the community.

For those who have written in response to Mr. Bryant's editorial professing years of expertise in journalism and writing - I implore you to share more of your wisdom and experience with this young journalist. Guidance, advice and mentorship is the only way any young writer can hope to improve. Mr. Bryant has quite clearly been told by his readers that the way he did his job is wrong. Now, I think it's time someone took the time to teach him how to do it right.
April 24, 2012 @ 10:42 pm Report Abuse
Forums message number 334563 has been flagged as offensive by a user.

Category:
Category 2:
Category 3:
message ID: 334563
Post On: April 24, 2012
Posted by User #: Outsider LookingIn
Posted by IP:

message:
I'm just an outsider looking in, who happened to stumble upon this site. I must profess,I'm not an expert on Barrhead, nor am I claiming to be an expert on religion.

But from what I've read, I pray that the hurt Mr. Bryant has caused to Barrhead through his "too little, too late" editorial will be forgiven in time. It seems to me that Mr. Bryant is a young journalist who is still struggling to find his voice and place in the world. Undoubtedly, the "too little, too late" editorial was a profoundly inexplicable and offensive mistake on his part. However, it is worth remembering that he's offered to Barrhead what I can only hope is a truly heartfelt apology. Honestly, how many of us can truthfully say that we didn't make stupid mistakes in our first jobs?

Forgive me if I am incorrect, but when Jesus walked the earth, the people he chose to forgive were ones who had caused a great deal of hurt to their communities. True enough, I'm sure Mr. Bryant is not a scoundrel, thief or a criminal. But it is my humble opinion that it behooves any good Christian to follow the Lord's example by extending a hand of forgiveness to those who have wronged the community.

For those who have written in response to Mr. Bryant's editorial professing years of expertise in journalism and writing - I implore you to share more of your wisdom and experience with this young journalist. Guidance, advice and mentorship is the only way any young writer can hope to improve. Mr. Bryant has quite clearly been told by his readers that the way he did his job is wrong. Now, I think it's time someone took the time to teach him how to do it right.
   

Got something to say?

Post Comment

You haven't entered any comments to post!

The The Barrhead Leader welcomes your opinions and comments. We reserve the right to edit comments for length, style, legality and taste and reproduce them in print, electronic or otherwise. For further information, please contact the editor or publisher.

In order to post comments on our web site, you must validate your email address. An email was sent to you when you registered that included an activation link. If you have not yet done so, please click on the link to activate your account.

If you did not receive your activation email, please click here to have it resent.

In order to post comments, you must be logged in.

Already a member? Login here!

Not yet a member of the site? Register here!

Community Events Rss icon

May 2013
Saturday
25
S M T W T F S
2829301234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
2627282930311
Saturday Night Dance

Saturday Night Dance at the Westlock Legion every Saturday from September to May 2013. Next dance is Saturday, March 23rd, Dance to the music of Hi Lites. Call 780 349-4046 or Mel 349-2477 for details.
20130323,20130330,20130406,20130413,20130420,20130427,20130504,20130511,20130518,20130525